Why American Creators Are Ditching Pornhub for JustForFans (And What It Really Means)

💡 The Real 2025 Showdown: Pornhub vs JustForFans in the U.S.

Alright, let’s get real for a sec. If you’re in the U.S. and even remotely tuned into the online adult creator scene, you know it’s been a wild year. Between Supreme Court rulings, new ID laws, and a vibe shift in how folks want to support their favorite creators, the old “tube site vs subscription platform” debate just got a LOT more complicated.

So, why are so many American creators eyeing JustForFans as their new home—and what’s really changing on the ground? The short answer: money, safety, and control. The long answer? Well, let’s dig in, because what’s happening right now might just flip the whole industry upside down.

Pornhub used to be the king of traffic, serving up billions of free views a month and letting creators cash in on ad revenue (hey, if you could get noticed among the sea of uploads). But with new state laws forcing age verification—like in Texas, where you now need legit ID to even enter the site—the old “just click and watch” model is falling apart [PCMag, 2025-06-30]. Meanwhile, JustForFans operates more like OnlyFans: you pay to play, creators own their content, and strict checks keep things safer (if a bit less wild).

The question isn’t just “which pays more,” but—where do creators actually feel safe, get paid fairly, and still have a shot at building a loyal fanbase? And with current events shaking things up, the stakes (and the money) have never been higher.

📊 Pornhub vs JustForFans: 2025 Platform Comparison

What’s the big takeaway from this table? For starters, JustForFans gives creators a bigger slice of the pie—an 80% revenue share, compared to Pornhub’s 60–80% (and that higher end is pretty rare unless you’re in their top tier or running massive traffic). But the real kicker is control: on JustForFans, you decide what goes out, who pays, and you can boot freeloaders or creeps at will. On Pornhub, it’s still the wild west—your vids can get pirated, re-uploaded, or buried under a million “related” thumbnails.

On the safety front, JustForFans’ ID + selfie verification is a pain to set up, but it’s way stricter than Pornhub’s old “click yes if you’re 18” approach (which, let’s be honest, everyone ignored). But since the Supreme Court rulings in June, even Pornhub has been forced to introduce real-world ID checks in states like Texas and Louisiana [Fox News, 2025-06-30]. That means casual browsers are dropping off—fast.

And yeah, Pornhub still wins on sheer numbers, with tens of millions of monthly U.S. users. But the trend lines are shifting. Creators are realizing: a smaller, more loyal fanbase (that actually pays) beats viral traffic that pays peanuts.

💡 Money, Safety, and the New Rules of the Game

Let’s unpack what this all means for real creators—not big studios or influencers with teams, but the average hustler trying to pay rent and maybe save up for a vacation.

First, payouts. On tube sites like Pornhub, you’re fighting for pennies unless you hit the jackpot with a viral video or get into their exclusive partner programs. Ad revenue is shaky (big brands steer clear of adult content), and with new legal headaches, even the old faithfuls are looking for the exits [Economic Times, 2025-06-30].

JustForFans (and similar platforms) flips the script. You set the price, fans subscribe, and you pocket most of it—plus tips, custom content, and more. It ain’t “get rich quick,” but at least you know what you’re getting. And in 2025, with banking crackdowns and more states threatening to ban porn unless there’s hardcore ID checks, predictability is gold.

Now, safety. Let’s be blunt: the old way was risky as hell. Piracy, deepfakes, and zero control over who watches or shares your work. But after the Supreme Court greenlit states to require strict age checks for porn, even the biggest tube sites are scrambling to keep up [Fox News, 2025-06-30]. JustForFans (and to some extent OnlyFans) already had those systems, so for them, it’s business as usual.

What about fans? Sure, some complain about “jumping through hoops” just to watch adult content, especially in states with new laws. But the flip side is—if you’re a creator, you get fewer bots, fewer minors sneaking in, and a safer, more respectful vibe overall. That’s good for everyone, even if it feels like a hassle at first.

And finally, control. This is where JustForFans really shines. You’re not just uploading into the void, hoping for a lucky break. You can build a real brand, talk to your fans directly, and decide where your content lives (and dies). That’s worth a lot in 2025’s crazy, lawsuit-happy climate.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ How do the new U.S. age verification laws affect creators on Pornhub and JustForFans?

💬 In states like Texas, Louisiana, and more, platforms like Pornhub now require strict age checks for users—and yes, it’s a pain for fans and creators. JustForFans, being a paywall platform, already had stricter verification, so it feels less disruptive there. For creators, expect more paperwork and possibly a dip in casual traffic on tube sites, at least for now!

🛠️ Is switching from Pornhub to JustForFans really worth it for American creators in 2025?

💬 Honestly, if you want more control, better pay, and a safer vibe (especially with all the new laws and payment headaches), JustForFans is looking like the smart bet for indie creators. But if you rely on viral traffic or want truly massive reach, Pornhub’s still the giant—just with more red tape these days.

🧠 What’s the biggest mistake U.S. creators make when picking between these two?

💬 Easy: assuming you can just copy-paste the same hustle and win on both. The audiences are different, the rules are different, and the money flows differently too. Do your homework, network with creators who’ve tried both, and don’t sleep on the legal stuff—it’s changing fast!

🧩 Final Thoughts…

Here’s the bottom line: The old “go where the traffic is” advice doesn’t cut it anymore. With laws changing, platforms forced to get serious about age checks, and creators finally demanding fair pay and respect, the whole game is shifting.

If you’re a U.S. creator tired of fighting algorithm roulette, getting ripped off by piracy, or just feeling exposed on the big tube sites, 2025 is the year to explore subscription platforms like JustForFans. It’s not instant fame, but it’s a heck of a lot more sustainable—and a whole lot less stressful.

As always, stay informed, watch out for new laws (they’re coming fast), and don’t be afraid to experiment until you find what feels right for you and your fans.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Supreme Court says Texas can restrict porn. Here’s what it actually accomplishes
🗞️ Source: Express News – 📅 2025-06-30
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Young women are getting strokes and seizures — it’s time to ban ‘choking’ porn
🗞️ Source: Irish Examiner – 📅 2025-06-30
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Porn Star-Turned-Pastor Praises SCOTUS Ruling Protecting Kids from Adult Content
🗞️ Source: Movieguide – 📅 2025-06-30
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.